
Renouncing in 2027 as a covered expatriate? Your UK home is deemed sold the day before, with no section 121 relief on the IRS view. The dollar maths.
If you renounce US citizenship in 2027 as a covered expatriate, your UK home is treated as sold at fair market value on the day before your expatriation date. The IRS says the $250,000 home-sale exclusion does not apply to that deemed sale, so the house relies on its share of the 2027 exclusion amount instead.
Only if you are a covered expatriate, and then yes. §877A treats all property of a covered expatriate as sold for its fair market value on the day before the expatriation date. There is no carve-out for a home, wherever it sits. If you are not covered, renouncing creates no deemed sale and your home is untouched by the exit tax.
Whether you are covered turns on three tests. For a 2027 expatriation, Rev. Proc. 2026-35 sets the income test at average annual net income tax of more than $218,000 for the period before the expatriation date. The net worth test is $2 million or more on the expatriation date and is not indexed. The third test is a failure to certify full compliance on Form 8854, and it applies whatever your wealth. The home often matters most to the net worth test, because a London property bought a decade or two ago can carry someone past the line on its own.
Certain dual citizens from birth and certain young renunciants escape the first two tests, never the certification test. Check the conditions in the Form 8854 instructions before relying on them.
The IRS says no. Its international practice unit on the mark-to-market regime states that the §121 exclusion does not apply to the deemed sale. Practitioners point out that §121(e) only switches the exclusion off for the older §877 regime, and argue the question is open. Until a court or formal guidance settles it, plan on the IRS view.
The practice unit is internal IRS training material, marked as a draft, and is not authority a taxpayer can cite. It is still the clearest statement of how an examiner is trained to read the rule. The contrary argument, that Congress never extended §121(e) to §877A, is respectable, but it belongs in a considered, signed return position rather than an assumption.
Read the two exclusions for what they are. §121 gives $250,000 of gain on a real sale, or $500,000 on a joint return where the ownership and use conditions in 26 U.S.C. §121 are met. The §877A exclusion is one lifetime amount spread across all your gain assets. On the IRS view only the second reaches the deemed sale.
The gain is the dollar value of the home on the day before the expatriation date, minus your dollar basis. Basis is the purchase price plus capital improvements, each converted at the exchange rate on the day you paid it. Value is converted at the rate on the valuation date. Currency movement is part of the gain.
No. The deemed sale measures gain as value minus basis, and the debt secured on the property plays no part in that calculation. A house worth a lot with a large mortgage produces the same deemed gain as the same house owned outright. The mortgage matters only to the net worth test, where liabilities are subtracted.
So someone with modest equity can pass under the net worth line, be covered through the income test or a certification failure, and still have the gain computed on the whole house. If the mortgage is in sterling, ask your preparer separately whether the change in the dollar value of the loan since you took it out has its own consequence. It is a different question from the house and is not settled by any of the IRS guidance on the deemed sale.
Here is our own illustration, in thousands of US dollars to keep the table readable. A single covered expatriate renounces at the London embassy in 2027. The day before, she owns:
| Asset (US$ thousands) | Value day before | US basis | Built-in gain |
|---|---|---|---|
| London house, main home | 2,100 | 900 | 1,200 |
| Taxable brokerage account | 700 | 400 | 300 |
| Total gain assets | 2,800 | 1,300 | 1,500 |
A mortgage of 600 is outstanding and changes none of these numbers.
Route A, keep the house into the deemed sale (IRS view, no §121). IRS Notice 2009-85 allocates the exclusion pro rata to each gain asset. The house carries 1,200 of the 1,500 total gain, so it takes 1,200/1,500 of the 940 exclusion, which is 752. Its taxable gain is 448. The brokerage account takes 188 and leaves 112. Total taxable deemed gain: 560.
Route A on the contrary view (§121 first). If §121 removed 250 from the house before the allocation, total gain would be 1,250 and the taxable deemed gain would fall to 310. The disputed point is worth 250 of taxable gain here, which is the full §121 cap.
Route B, sell the house as a citizen before the appointment. She meets the use and ownership conditions, so §121 shelters 250 and 950 is taxed on her ordinary return. The deemed sale then covers only the brokerage gain of 300, which the 940 exclusion wipes out. Total taxable gain: 950, and the exclusion goes largely unused.
On these facts, keeping the house is better than selling it, even on the IRS view. The common "sell first" advice was written for someone leaving a US home. Change the mix, with a smaller house gain and a large share portfolio, and the answer can flip. It is arithmetic, not a rule.
Nothing. Renouncing US citizenship is not a disposal for UK capital gains tax, and your home keeps its Private Residence Relief history. If you later sell it as your only or main residence, the gain is usually exempt in the UK. That is exactly why the deemed sale bites: it taxes a gain no UK tax will ever fall on, so there is no UK tax to credit against the US charge.
The real-sale version of this mismatch, where Private Residence Relief and §121 interact, is covered in what happens when a US citizen sells a UK main home. The deemed sale is harsher in one respect: on the IRS view, §121 is not there to soften it.
For a UK home, usually nothing on the US side. Once you have expatriated you are a nonresident alien, and gain on foreign real estate is generally outside US tax for a nonresident. A home in the US is different: §897 does not apply to the deemed sale but does apply to the later actual sale, using the basis already adjusted for the gain taken into account.
That adjustment is the hidden benefit of the deemed sale. Notice 2009-85 increases basis by the gain recognised on the deemed sale, measured before the exclusion amount. So a US property that has been through the deemed sale is taxed later only on growth after the day before expatriation. For a UK home, the later sale belongs to the UK alone, where Private Residence Relief normally applies if it is still your main residence.
One trap: a sale in the weeks before the appointment is a real sale made while you are still a citizen. It is reported on the citizen part of your dual-status return for the year, not in the deemed sale. Route B above is that case.
Yes, property by property. §877A(b) lets a covered expatriate elect to defer the tax attributable to a particular asset until it is sold, or until death. The election is irrevocable, interest runs for the whole deferral period, adequate security must be provided to the IRS, and you must waive treaty rights that would stop the IRS collecting. A house is the obvious candidate because there is no cash in it.
What counts as acceptable security is agreed with the IRS, so start early: an election without it fails.
| Step | Why it matters | When |
|---|---|---|
| Confirm covered or not | Not covered means no deemed sale | First |
| Rebuild dollar basis: purchase plus improvements, each at its own date's rate | A missing invoice is gain you pay tax on | Months ahead |
| Settle ownership share if the house is joint with a non-US spouse | Only your share is your property; the split needs a written position | Months ahead |
| Run Route A and Route B with the year's exclusion | Sell-first is not always right | Before booking the appointment |
| Decide on the §121 position with your preparer | The IRS view and the contrary view can differ by the full cap | Before the return is drafted |
| Order a RICS valuation dated the day before the oath | Fair market value is the IRS test, not an agent's asking price | Immediately after the appointment |
| Decide on deferral and agree security | No security, no election | Before the return is due |
For a renunciation, the expatriation date is the day you renounce before a US diplomatic or consular officer, provided the State Department later confirms it with a Certificate of Loss of Nationality. The certificate can take months, but it relates back to the oath. Everything about the house, from value to exchange rate, is fixed the day before that oath.
A sharp move in sterling between booking and attending changes the dollar gain on a house you have not touched, so do the basis work before you book. The year also matters: an appointment in 2027 uses the 2027 exclusion of $940,000, while a 2026 appointment would have used $910,000. The full list of what is swept into the deemed sale, and how ownership is decided, is in our guide to which assets are deemed sold.
We model the house both ways before an appointment is booked, from the dollar basis to the exclusion allocation and the deferral numbers. The wider sequence, from compliance years to Form 8854, sits in our US citizenship renunciation service. Unresolved points like the §121 dispute are escalated for human review, and every return and Form 8854 is reviewed and signed by an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified. You can see pricing or book a consultation to have your home run through both routes.