Gold spheres in a glass case, like UK ISA holdings in the exit tax deemed sale
Cross-border · Journal

US Exit Tax and a UK ISA: Inside the Deemed Sale

A UK ISA is not a pension or tax-deferred account under 877A, so its holdings are deemed sold. US basis, PFIC funds and the exclusion, explained.

Published 11 November 2026 · Reviewed by a licensed professional
To the US exit tax the ISA wrapper is see-through: each holding inside is deemed sold on its own US basis the day before expatriation.

For a covered expatriate, a UK ISA gets no special US exit-tax treatment. It is not a pension, a specified tax deferred account or a nongrantor trust interest, so every holding inside it is deemed sold at fair market value on the day before expatriation. What the ISA holds, not the wrapper, decides the tax.

Key takeaways

Why does a UK ISA fall into the deemed sale?

The mark-to-market rule in §877A(a) treats all property of a covered expatriate as sold for its fair market value on the day before the expatriation date. §877A(c) then removes three categories, and each one has its own regime: deferred compensation items, specified tax deferred accounts and interests in nongrantor trusts. Property that falls outside all three stays in the deemed sale. Testing an ISA against each one settles the matter.

§877A(c) carve-outWhat the statute requiresDoes an ordinary ISA qualify?
Deferred compensation item, §877A(d)(4)A US plan interest, a foreign pension plan or similar retirement arrangement, deferred compensation, or a right to property for servicesNo. A cash or stocks-and-shares ISA has no retirement condition, is not tied to employment, and is accessible without reaching any retirement age
Specified tax deferred account, §877A(e)(2)A closed list: US IRAs (except SEP and SIMPLE), §529, §529A, §530, §223 and §220 accountsNo. Every item on the list is a US statutory account, and the list has no catch-all for foreign equivalents
Nongrantor trust interest, §877A(f)A beneficial interest in a trust that is not a grantor trust as to the expatriateNo. An ISA is a custody arrangement. Even on the view that it is a trust, it would be a grantor trust, so this carve-out still would not apply

The ISA's tax-free status in Britain does not move it into any of the three. (The US-UK treaty's definition of a "pension scheme" does not cover an ISA either, though the exit tax is a separate test.)

Whose property is inside the ISA?

If the investments belonged to the ISA manager, they could not be deemed sold as yours. They do not.

Regulation 4(6) of the Individual Savings Account Regulations 1998 requires the account terms to provide that the account investments are in the beneficial ownership of the account investor. Legal title sits with the account manager or its nominee. In plain terms, the manager is a custodian and you are the owner.

That matters because of how the US decides what you own for the exit tax. IRS Notice 2009-85, section 3.A, says a covered expatriate is treated as owning any interest in property that would be in their gross estate for federal estate tax purposes, as if they had died the day before expatriation. Shares, funds and deposits that you beneficially own would be in your gross estate. So each line in the ISA is deemed sold separately, at its own fair market value, with its own basis.

Some US practitioners argue that an ISA is not a foreign trust at all, because the manager has no fiduciary role and the holder controls the investments. For the exit tax that debate does not matter. If an ISA were a trust, the investor would still be taxed as owner, which makes it a grantor arrangement outside the nongrantor-trust carve-out.

What US basis does each ISA holding have?

Many people go wrong here. The account value on the provider's portal is a sterling figure, and it shows nothing about US basis. For the deemed sale, each holding needs:

If you have filed correctly every year, the annual returns already needed these figures. If they treated the ISA as tax-free, the basis records are usually missing as well, and that gap has to be closed inside the compliance years Form 8854 asks you to certify.

What happens to PFIC funds inside a stocks-and-shares ISA?

This is the part that no ranking page connects, and it changes the size of the tax bill.

Most stocks-and-shares ISAs hold UK OEICs, unit trusts or Irish-domiciled ETFs. For a US person each of these is normally a passive foreign investment company. If you made no election, the fund is a "section 1291 fund", and the Form 8621 instructions are clear about a sale: the entire gain from disposing of a section 1291 fund is treated as an excess distribution. That gain is spread back over your holding period. The amounts allocated to earlier years are taxed at the highest rate in force for each of those years, with an interest charge on top, and only the current-year share is ordinary income in the year of sale.

The deemed sale is a disposition of every fund you hold. The natural reading is that a non-electing fund's deemed-sale gain goes through §1291 like any other disposal. That is the starting point, though, not a settled answer. Notice 2009-85 does not mention passive foreign investment companies or §1291 at all, and neither do the Form 8854 instructions; we searched both texts. The open question is how the exclusion amount works against a §1291 gain. The exclusion reduces what would be "includible in gross income" by reason of the deemed sale. Under §1291, the part of an excess distribution allocated to earlier years is not included in gross income at all. It produces a separate deferred tax amount instead. No IRS guidance says how the two fit together, and we do not publish a computation that pretends otherwise.

The status of each fund therefore has to be established before the date is fixed:

Our guide to the QEF and mark-to-market elections explains how each election is made and when it is too late to make it cleanly.

And a cash ISA?

A cash ISA usually gives the smallest result. Sterling deposits have no gain in sterling, but measured in dollars they are worth a different amount on the day before expatriation than when paid in. The character of that currency difference is a technical point for whoever prepares the return; assume neither that it is zero nor that it is capital gain. It is usually small, but on a large, long-held balance it is worth working out.

A worked example, indexed to 100

To keep the arithmetic readable, the example below is in index points rather than currency. Assume a covered expatriate holds a stocks-and-shares ISA worth 100 (in dollar terms) on the day before the expatriation date:

HoldingValueUS basisGainUS character
Shares in a single UK-listed company402515Capital gain, shares the exclusion with the rest of the gain property
UK-domiciled index OEIC, no election453015§1291 excess distribution: spread back, top-rate tax plus interest; exclusion interaction unresolved
Cash held in the ISA1515nil in sterlingPossible currency difference in dollars, to be worked out
Total1007030Half the gain is outside capital-gain treatment

HMRC sees nothing. The US sees a gain of 30, half of it not capital gain. The common summary that "net gain above the exclusion is taxed at capital gains rates" is right for the first line and wrong for the second. If a house and a share portfolio already use up the exclusion, the PFIC line drives the bill.

How much does the exclusion amount shelter?

The exclusion amount depends on the year of expatriation. It is $910,000 for a 2026 expatriation. For 2027, Rev. Proc. 2026-35, section 3.40, sets it at $940,000 for taxable years beginning in 2027. It is not a separate allowance for the ISA. Notice 2009-85 requires it to be allocated across all of the built-in gain property you own on the day before. Your ISA holdings share it pro rata with your home, any taxable investment account, private company shares and anything else standing at a gain. The deemed sale itself, including valuation and that allocation, is covered in which assets are deemed sold.

The exclusion does not touch a UK pension, which runs through the deferred compensation rules instead. Someone with both a SIPP and an ISA is dealing with two different mechanics on the same day.

Should you change the ISA before renouncing?

Sometimes, but not by reflex. Selling inside the ISA before the date does not avoid US tax. It recognises the gain early, outside the deemed sale, so the exclusion amount does not reach it at all, and a non-electing fund still goes through §1291. What can help:

SituationWhat to consider before the date
Fund ISA, no elections, long holding periodModel the §1291 cost now. Whether an earlier actual disposal beats the deemed sale is a calculation, not a rule of thumb, and it gives up any share of the exclusion
Basis records missingRebuild them from contract notes and annual statements while the provider still holds them
Prior returns treated the ISA as tax-freeFix the compliance years first. Otherwise you fail the certification test whatever the ISA is worth
Lifetime ISA heldGet a written position on its classification before relying on any treatment (see below)
Not a covered expatriateNone of this applies. The ISA simply stops being a US reporting item after the final dual-status year

The Lifetime ISA is the one ISA type we do not classify here. Its tie to age-based access and its government bonus give it features of a retirement product. Whether that makes it a "similar retirement arrangement" under §877A(d)(4)(B), rather than deemed-sale property, has not been addressed by any IRS source we have found. We treat it as a question for a signed position, not a blog sentence.

Where we fit

Before any appointment is booked, we schedule the ISA line by line beside the rest of the balance sheet: basis per holding, each fund's PFIC regime, the dollar figure on the cash, and the share of the exclusion. Open questions like those above are escalated for human review, not decided by default, and every return and statement is reviewed and signed by an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified.

If renunciation is on your horizon, start with our renouncing US citizenship service, check pricing, or book a consultation to have the ISA modelled before the date is fixed.

Frequently asked questions

What happens to my ISA if I renounce US citizenship?+
In the UK, nothing: renouncing is not a disposal and the ISA keeps its tax-free status. On the US side it depends on whether you are a covered expatriate. If you are, every holding in the ISA is treated as sold at fair market value on the day before your expatriation date, because an ISA is not a pension, a specified tax deferred account or a nongrantor trust interest under IRC section 877A. If you are not covered, there is no deemed sale.
Do I have to sell my ISA before renouncing US citizenship?+
No. Nothing requires you to sell, and selling does not avoid US tax. An actual sale before the expatriation date is taxed in the ordinary way and gets no share of the exit-tax exclusion amount, which only applies to the deemed sale. Whether an earlier sale is better or worse depends on your basis, the PFIC status of any funds, and the rest of your balance sheet, so it needs to be modelled before the date is fixed.
Is an ISA a foreign trust?+
The IRS has not ruled on it. The ISA Regulations 1998 put beneficial ownership of the investments in the account investor and legal title in the manager or its nominee, which looks like custody rather than a trust, and some US practitioners argue an ISA is not a trust for that reason. For the exit tax the question does not change the outcome: even if it were a trust, the investor would be taxed as owner, so the nongrantor-trust exception in section 877A would not apply.
Is a stocks and shares ISA a PFIC?+
The ISA itself is not, but most of what it holds usually is. UK OEICs, unit trusts and Irish-domiciled ETFs are normally passive foreign investment companies for a US person. Shares in individual companies held inside the ISA are not PFICs simply because of the wrapper. Each fund's election history decides how its gain is taxed, both every year and in an exit-tax deemed sale.
Is an ISA a specified tax deferred account?+
No. Section 877A(e)(2) defines specified tax deferred accounts as a closed list of US accounts: individual retirement plans other than SEP and SIMPLE arrangements, section 529 and 529A programmes, Coverdell education savings accounts, health savings accounts and Archer MSAs. A UK ISA is none of these, and the list has no catch-all for foreign equivalents, so an ISA's holdings stay in the mark-to-market deemed sale.

Related reading

Is your family exposed on both sides of the Atlantic?
Trusts, estates and lifetime gifts are where the US and UK rules collide hardest — a structure that works in one country is often penalised in the other. We work the cross-border position first, then the returns behind it.
US–UK private client tax →
Book a free consultation  ·  See pricing

← All articles