
Renouncing with UK carry? Why one 83(b) election decides whether the US exit tax treats it as a deemed sale or as ordinary income.
For a covered expatriate, UK carried interest goes one of two ways the day before you renounce. Vested carry, or carry covered by a properly reported section 83(b) election, is deemed sold at fair market value. Unvested carry with no election is treated as vesting that day and taxed as ordinary income, with no exclusion.
Which of the two you get is decided years earlier, usually by a one-page election someone in the fund's legal team sent you at grant. This article explains how the US exit tax sorts a carry interest, why a UK fund partnership almost always lands in the harsher category when the paperwork is missing, and what the UK does with the same carry after you have handed in your passport.
Yes, if you are a covered expatriate, but not always in the way people assume. Section 877A treats all your property as sold on the day before the expatriation date, unless it is one of the excepted classes. A carry interest can be ordinary property or, if it has not been taken into account under section 83, a deferred compensation item with its own, stricter rules.
Whether you are covered at all depends on three tests: average income tax liability, a net worth of $2 million or more on the expatriation date, and five years of certified compliance. Carry matters to the second one. Its value goes on the Form 8854 balance sheet, and a fund that has had a strong few years can push a manager over the line on carry alone. The wider route from consular appointment to certificate of loss of nationality is covered on our page about renouncing US citizenship from the UK.
When it was received for services and has not yet been "taken into account" under section 83. IRS Notice 2009-85, section 5.B(1)d, sets three conditions for that: the interest was transferred to you, it has either vested or you made a valid 83(b) election, and your returns reported any amount includible and the tax was paid.
All three are needed. That third condition is the one fund managers rarely think about, because for a profits interest the amount reported at grant is normally nil. A nil figure is fine. What causes trouble is an unvested grant where nobody filed an 83(b) election, often on the strength of advice that the profits-interest safe harbour made one unnecessary. For the exit tax, the notice's wording looks only at vesting or an election, and the safe harbour is not mentioned. Treat any unvested grant without an election as a deferred compensation item until a professional has told you otherwise.
| Your carry grant on the day before expatriation | Exit-tax bucket | What is taxed | Exclusion amount? | Deferral election? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vested, reported on your returns | Mark-to-market property, section 877A(a) | Fair market value less basis, as gain | Yes, shared across all gain assets | Yes, with security and a treaty waiver |
| Unvested, valid 83(b) election made and reported | Mark-to-market property, section 877A(a) | Fair market value less basis, as gain | Yes | Yes |
| Unvested, no 83(b) election, UK fund partnership as payor | Ineligible deferred compensation, section 877A(d)(2) | Value ignoring lapse restrictions, as ordinary income | No | No |
| Unvested, no election, a US payor willing to withhold | Possibly eligible deferred compensation, section 877A(d)(1) | 30 percent withheld from later taxable payments | No | Not needed |
It is treated as vesting on the day before you expatriate. Notice 2009-85 says an ineligible item of this kind becomes transferable and free of any substantial risk of forfeiture that day, so its fair market value, disregarding lapse restrictions and less anything you paid, is compensation income on your final return as a citizen.
The route to the gentler eligible treatment is closed in practice. An item is only eligible if the payor is a US person, or a non-US person who elects to be treated as one, and the IRS has still not published how a foreign payor makes that election. So the item is ineligible, and you report it by checking the ineligible box on Form W-8CE and including the value on your Form 1040.
Two further points make this bucket expensive. The exclusion amount in section 877A(a)(3) only reduces gain arising from the mark-to-market sale, so it cannot shelter this income. And the deferral election in section 877A(b) applies only to property treated as sold under subsection (a), so the tax is due with the final return. Our article on the three exit-tax buckets and deferred compensation sets out both rules from the statute.
No. Section 877A(d)(5) removes deferred compensation from the rules only to the extent it is attributable to services performed outside the United States while the covered expatriate was not a citizen or resident. A US citizen working in London performs services outside the US, but as a citizen, so the second condition fails.
The exception helps two kinds of service: work done abroad before someone became a citizen or green card holder, and work done after expatriation. Notice 2009-85, Example 14, shows the second case, where an eligible item keeps vesting after renunciation and the post-expatriation share drops out. A manager who has been a US citizen since birth gets nothing from it for the years already worked in London, however long they have lived in Britain.
On estate-tax principles. Notice 2009-85 fixes fair market value for the deemed sale as if you had died on the day before the expatriation date. For carry, that means what a willing buyer would pay for your share of future profits, reflecting the fund's current marks, its hurdle and the chance of clawback.
Liquidation value is the obvious starting point, and the wrong place to stop. A fund just under its hurdle may show nil if wound up today, yet a buyer would still pay for the upside. Equally, a large carry figure in internal statements may deserve a real discount for illiquidity and clawback risk. Ask the fund for its valuation pack as at the day before your appointment, not the last quarter end, and have the figure supported independently. The same number decides your net worth test, so it does two jobs.
It may, and we prepare returns on that footing while flagging it for review. Section 1061 recharacterises long-term gain on an applicable partnership interest as short-term unless the holding period exceeds 3 years. Nothing in the exit-tax rules switches it off, but no IRS guidance addresses the two together.
For a carry grant held well beyond three years, the main question is the fund's own holding periods. The final section 1061 regulations include a look-through rule for some disposals where most of the partnership's assets have been held for shorter periods. For a recent grant that is mark-to-market property because of an 83(b) election, the recharacterisation may convert most of the deemed gain to short-term. Section 751 can also pull part of any partnership-interest gain into ordinary income where the fund holds receivables or inventory-type items. Each of these is a computation for the reviewing professional, not a default.
Maya is a US citizen, born in Boston, who has spent most of her career at a London private equity firm. She plans to renounce in 2027 and is a covered expatriate on the net worth test. Her carry sits in two English limited partnerships. The figures are illustrative and shown in thousands of US dollars.
| Item | Fund II carry (granted 2019, protective 83(b) filed and reported) | Fund III carry (granted 2025, unvested, no election) |
|---|---|---|
| Value on the day before expatriation | 1,100 | 400 |
| Basis | 50 | Not relevant |
| Amount brought into tax | 1,050 deemed gain | 400 ordinary income |
| Exclusion amount available | Yes, against the gain | No |
| Deferral election available | Yes | No |
The exclusion amount for a 2027 expatriation is $940,000 (it was $910,000 for 2026), and it is shared across every asset Maya holds at a gain. If Fund II were her only one, her taxable deemed gain would shrink to a small fraction of its value. Fund III, worth barely a third as much, would be taxed in full as compensation, at ordinary rates, with the tax due with her final return. The smaller interest produces the bigger bill, and the only difference between them is a form filed in 2019.
Now the UK half. Maya stays in London. When Fund II pays out in later years, HMRC treats that carry as profits of a deemed trade and charges income tax and Class 4 National Insurance on it. Renouncing did not make the carry arise for UK purposes, so the UK charge is not reduced by what the IRS already collected, and Maya has no US return left to claim a credit on.
Very likely, if you stay UK resident or the carry relates to investment management you performed in the UK. The revised UK regime applies from 6 April 2026 and taxes carry when it arises, as trading profits, not when the US says you sold it.
So the two charges fall years apart, on different events and under different labels: a deemed capital gain or compensation in the US, trading profit in the UK. Whether the US-UK treaty gives any relief for that gap after you are no longer a US person is a question we take to a licensed professional on each file. If you elect to defer the US tax on mark-to-market carry, remember the price: adequate security, interest for the whole period, and an irrevocable waiver of treaty rights on that property. Our earlier piece on carried interest for US citizens in UK funds covers the credit mismatch that applies while you are still a citizen.
All of this is preparation for a return a professional reviews and a Form 8854 you sign yourself. Our reviewer on US-UK work is an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified. If you hold carry and are thinking about renouncing, start with the election file, not the valuation. It is the cheapest document in the whole exercise and the one that decides how the rest is taxed.