
Renouncing with a UK Ltd? How the US exit tax values your company shares, when section 1248 makes it a dividend, and why the UK sees no sale.
If you are a covered expatriate, shares in your own UK limited company are treated as sold at fair market value on the day before you renounce. Part of that gain may be taxed as a dividend under section 1248, earlier GILTI inclusions reduce it, and the UK sees no disposal at all.
That last point is the one owner-managers miss. The United States taxes a sale that never happened, and Britain later taxes the real sale from your original cost. Nothing in either system automatically lines the two up. This article walks through the company-share piece of the exit tax for an American who runs a UK Ltd, in the order the numbers are built.
Yes, if you are a covered expatriate. Section 877A treats all of your property as sold at fair market value on the day before the expatriation date, and private company shares are not one of the four excepted classes. A one-person consultancy counts like a listed holding; only the valuation is harder.
Whether you are covered at all turns on three alternative tests: average income tax, a $2 million net worth, and five years of certified compliance. The company matters to two of them. Its shares go on the Form 8854 balance sheet for the net worth test, and a missing Form 5471 is one of the commonest reasons an owner fails certification. The wider route, from the consular appointment to the certificate of loss of nationality, is covered in our guide to renouncing US citizenship from the UK.
Under estate-tax rules. IRS Notice 2009-85 says fair market value for the deemed sale is fixed under section 2031, as though the covered expatriate had died on the day before expatriation, and that the special valuation rules in sections 2701 to 2704 apply as if the interest went to a family member.
For a private company that points to the familiar willing-buyer, willing-seller exercise: earnings, net assets, comparable businesses, and whatever discount a minority or unmarketable holding genuinely deserves. A sole owner will struggle to argue a minority discount. A spouse holding a parallel block of shares may have a better case, but sections 2701 to 2704 exist precisely to stop family arrangements manufacturing discounts.
Two practical points come up in almost every owner-managed file we see. First, retained cash counts. A consultancy that has kept three years of profit in its bank account will rarely be valued at less than that cash, net of what it owes, so the deemed gain includes money the company has already paid UK corporation tax on. Second, the valuation date is fixed by the consular appointment, not by your accounting year end. Management accounts drawn to that day are far easier to defend than statutory accounts from months earlier. Our article on which assets go into the deemed sale and how each is valued covers the rest of the balance sheet.
Probably, in part. Section 1248 taxes gain on selling stock in a controlled foreign corporation as a dividend, up to the earnings and profits built up while you held it and it was a CFC. It applies where you held at least a tenth of the voting power at any point in the run-up to the sale, which a sole owner always does.
The statute reaches stock that another provision of the Code treats as sold, and section 877A does exactly that. Even so, Notice 2009-85 never mentions section 1248, and we have found no IRS guidance applying one to the other directly. We prepare these returns on the footing that section 1248 is likely to apply, and we flag it to the reviewing professional on every file rather than treating it as settled.
For a UK company the label may matter less than people fear. The IRS said in Notice 2004-70 that a section 1248 amount can be a qualified dividend if the company is a qualified foreign corporation. A UK trading company eligible for the US-UK treaty usually is, unless it is also a passive foreign investment company. An investment-holding UK company is where the PFIC question needs checking before anything else.
They can, in two ways. Each amount you included under section 951 or as GILTI (renamed net CFC tested income from 2026) increases your basis in the shares under section 961, which shrinks the deemed gain. Section 1248(d)(1) then removes the earnings behind those inclusions from the dividend calculation, so the same profit is not taxed twice.
The irony catches owners who elected the high-tax exclusion every year to keep their UK company out of GILTI. That election produced no inclusion, so no basis step-up and no previously taxed earnings. All of those retained profits are still untaxed for US purposes on the expatriation date, and all of them can sit inside the section 1248 slice. The two histories arrive at the deemed sale with very different numbers, and the Schedule P and basis records on past Forms 5471 are what prove which one you have.
| Element | Where it comes from | What it does to the deemed sale |
|---|---|---|
| Fair market value, day before expatriation | Section 877A(a); Notice 2009-85 (section 2031 principles) | Sets the deemed sale price |
| Original subscription cost | Share register, bank records | Starting basis, often nominal |
| Past GILTI and subpart F inclusions | Section 961 basis increase; Form 5471 Schedule P | Raises basis, reduces the gain |
| Untaxed earnings and profits | Company E&P while a CFC and held by you | Caps the section 1248 dividend slice |
| Earnings behind earlier inclusions | Section 1248(d)(1) | Excluded from the dividend slice |
| Exclusion amount for the year of expatriation | Section 877A(a)(3) | Shelters part of the total gain across all assets |
| UK base cost | UK capital gains rules | Unchanged by renunciation |
Dana is a US citizen who has lived in Manchester for twenty years and owns every share in a UK IT consultancy. She renounces in 2026 and is a covered expatriate under the net worth test. The figures below are illustrative and shown in thousands of US dollars.
| Step | US$ thousands |
|---|---|
| Agreed value of her shares on the day before expatriation | 2,400 |
| Basis: nominal subscription plus section 961 increases from past GILTI inclusions | 300 |
| Deemed gain on the shares | 2,100 |
| Earnings and profits accumulated while she held the shares | 1,500 |
| Less earnings behind her past inclusions, removed by section 1248(d)(1) | 300 |
| Section 1248 dividend slice | 1,200 |
| Remaining long-term capital gain | 900 |
The exclusion amount for a 2026 expatriation is $910,000, and it is shared pro rata across every asset Dana holds at a gain, her house and any investment account included. How that sharing interacts with the dividend slice is a computation we work through with the reviewing professional on each return. We do not assume it.
Now the UK half. Two years later, as a non-American living in Manchester, Dana sells the company to a buyer. HMRC measures her gain from the original nominal subscription, because renouncing was not a disposal and gave her no new UK base cost. The value the IRS already taxed is taxed again, in sterling, by the UK. Business Asset Disposal Relief may soften it if she still qualifies, but nothing credits the earlier US tax against it.
No. UK capital gains tax arises when you dispose of an asset, by selling it, giving it away or swapping it, as GOV.UK's own guidance lists. Giving up a passport is none of those. Your UK base cost stays where it was, and the UK has no exit charge of its own that would rebase the shares to the US value.
That leaves a mismatch in timing and in taxpayer. The US tax falls in the expatriation year, on a deemed event. The UK tax, if any, falls in the year of a real sale, when you are no longer a US person and have no US return to claim a credit on. Whether the US-UK treaty offers any relief for that gap is a question we take to a licensed professional case by case.
The deferral election under section 877A(b) postpones paying the US tax on the shares until you actually sell them, with security and interest. It aligns the cash flow with the UK sale, which helps liquidity. It does not, by itself, create a credit.
Usually, yes. Your final US return covers the part of the year you were a citizen, and you still owned and controlled the company then. Form 5471 belongs with that return, alongside Form 8854. Which filer categories apply turns on your ownership days, so check the current instructions rather than last year's habit.
The inclusion side changed too. For CFC tax years beginning after 31 December 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act replaced the old rule that only a shareholder on the last day of the company's year picked up subpart F income. A shareholder who owned stock on any day now shares in it by days of ownership, and net CFC tested income follows the same approach. Treasury proposed regulations on this in August 2026; they are not final. For a mid-year renunciation, that means a stub-period inclusion is now a real possibility, and any such inclusion also feeds back into share basis before the deemed sale.
If earlier years of Forms 5471 are missing, fix that first. A catch-up that involves a UK company has its own traps, set out in our note on streamlined filing with a UK limited company.
Every one of these is preparation, and every one feeds the Form 8854 and final return that a licensed human reviews and signs. Our reviewer on US-UK work is an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified. A company you built over two decades deserves a valuation and a basis history you can show to the IRS without flinching, and the day before your appointment is the last day either can still be fixed.