
Article 1(4) lets the US tax citizens as if the US-UK treaty did not exist. What Article 1(5), as amended in 2002, still lets an American in the UK claim.
The saving clause in Article 1(4) of the US-UK income tax treaty lets the United States tax its citizens, and the UK its residents, as if the treaty had never come into effect. Article 1(5) then hands back a short list of benefits, and that list decides which articles still cut an American's US bill.
Most guidance stops at "the treaty mostly doesn't help you". That is roughly true and practically useless. The better question is which benefit you want, whether it is blocked, and which paragraph saves it. This article answers that from the text as amended by the 2002 Protocol, because much of what ranks online quotes the unamended 2001 version.
It says that, apart from paragraph 5, a country "may tax its residents" (as decided under Article 4) "and by reason of citizenship may tax its citizens, as if this Convention had not come into effect." Only the US taxes by citizenship, so the second half is aimed at Americans. The first half binds both countries equally.
Three details matter more than the headline. "Residents" means treaty residents under Article 4, not residents under domestic law. The clause overrides every other article unless Article 1(5) names it. And it is mutual: the UK can apply its own law to a UK resident whatever the treaty says. That is why Article 17(1)(b), which makes the UK respect the tax-free status of a Roth IRA distribution, has to sit on the exceptions list to be worth anything.
The 2001 Convention text on treasury.gov is the starting point, but read it alongside the Protocol below. Sources that place the clause in paragraph 3, with exceptions in paragraph 4 citing Articles 23 to 25, are quoting the technical explanation of the 1975 treaty, still hosted on irs.gov. The numbering is not in dispute; that document is simply out of date.
Those listed in Article 1(5)(a), as replaced by Article I of the 2002 Protocol. That list covers the corresponding adjustment in Article 9(2); Article 17(1)(b), 17(3) and 17(5); paragraphs 1 and 5 of Article 18; and the whole of Articles 24, 25 and 26. Every other article gives a US citizen no relief from US tax.
The 2002 Protocol deleted the original paragraph 5 and replaced it. The new version added paragraph 5 of Article 18 to sub-paragraph (a) and the new Article 20A (Teachers) to sub-paragraph (b). Nothing else on the list changed.
Here is the clause read as a decision table, from the position of a US citizen who lives in the UK and is UK resident under Article 4.
| Treaty benefit you want | Blocked by the saving clause? | Paragraph that saves it, or what you use instead |
|---|---|---|
| UK salary exempt from US tax (Article 14) | Yes | None. Use Form 2555 under IRC section 911, or the credit on Form 1116 |
| Gains taxed only in your residence country (Article 13) | Yes | None. Relief comes through the Article 24 credit |
| Periodic UK pension taxed only in the UK (Article 17(1)(a)) | Yes | None. The US taxes it and the UK tax is creditable |
| Pension amount exempt in the scheme's home country stays exempt (Article 17(1)(b)) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| Lump sum taxed only in the scheme's country (Article 17(2)) | Yes | Not on the list. Any argument runs through 17(1)(b) and is contested |
| US social security taxed only where you live (Article 17(3)) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| Child support and alimony rules (Article 17(5)) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| No current tax on growth inside a pension in the other country (Article 18(1)) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| Relief for contributions to a home-country pension while working abroad (Article 18(2)) | Yes, for citizens and green card holders | Article 1(5)(b) protects it for others only |
| US relief for UK workplace pension contributions (Article 18(5)) | No | Article 1(5)(a), as amended in 2002 |
| Reduced US tax on US dividends or interest (Articles 10 and 11) | Yes, for US tax | Article 24(6) caps the UK credit and re-sources income for the US credit |
| Foreign tax credit (Article 24) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| Non-discrimination and mutual agreement (Articles 25 and 26) | No | Article 1(5)(a) |
| Government pay, student, teacher or diplomat exemptions (Articles 19, 20, 20A, 28) | Yes, for citizens and green card holders | Article 1(5)(b) protects them for others only |
Two rows need a warning. Article 25 is preserved, but Article 25(1) compares you with nationals "particularly with respect to taxation on worldwide income", so it cannot be turned against citizenship-based taxation. And on lump sums, practitioners part company. The Treasury technical explanation says a UK-resident US citizen is subject to US tax on a pension lump sum; some advisers argue 17(1)(b) protects the UK tax-free portion. That is a filing position, not a settled answer.
Sub-paragraph (a) protects benefits for everyone, citizens and green card holders included. Sub-paragraph (b) protects benefits only for individuals who are "neither citizens of, nor have been admitted for permanent residence in" the taxing country. In US terms, (b) is for visa holders who become US resident under domestic rules, not for Americans.
The (b) list is short: Article 18(2) pension contributions, Article 19 government service, Article 20 students, Article 20A teachers and Article 28 diplomats. A British academic on a US visa who becomes resident under the substantial presence test can still claim Article 20A. Take a green card and that protection goes.
Yes, under Article 18(5), if its conditions are met. A US citizen resident in the UK and employed there by a UK-resident employer or a UK permanent establishment can exclude contributions to that employer's UK scheme from US income. Benefits accrued and employer contributions made in that period also stay out of US taxable income.
The conditions rule out more people than they let in:
A personal pension or SIPP you fund yourself, outside an employer arrangement, is the hard case, and the treaty does not clearly reach it. Excluding income on the strength of Article 18(5) overrides the Code, which is exactly the kind of treaty-based return position that Form 8833 disclosure exists for.
Only while they are US residents under Article 4. The clause reaches "residents" as the treaty defines them, plus citizens. A green card holder who lives in the UK and is resident here under the Article 4 tie-breaker is neither, so the US cannot use Article 1(4) against them on that income.
Article 4(2) adds a gate before the tie-breaker: a citizen or green card holder counts as a US treaty resident only with a substantial presence, permanent home or habitual abode in the US. Claiming UK residence under the tie-breaker is reported on Form 8833 with a non-resident return. For a long-term resident, that claim can count as expatriation under section 877A, so it is a decision to take deliberately, not a box to tick.
Sometimes. Article 1(6) treats a former citizen or long-term resident as a citizen if losing that status had "as one of its principal purposes the avoidance of tax". The extension lasts 10 years from loss of status, covers only income from sources in that country, and does not reach anyone who gave up status before 6 February 1995.
Purpose is judged under the former country's own law; on the US side, the technical explanation ties it to section 877. In practice it bites on the US dividends or US rent of former Americans in the UK, not on their UK salary.
It divides the work between the two countries. The UK credits only the US tax a non-citizen UK resident would have paid under the treaty. The US then credits the UK tax left after that credit, but never so far that US tax falls below what the UK credited. Article 24(6)(d) re-sources enough income to make the US credit usable.
Without re-sourcing, a US dividend stays US-source income, the Form 1116 limitation allows no credit against it, and the American in London pays tax twice in full. The US-side mechanics, including the separate Form 1116 category for treaty re-sourced income, are covered in our guide to re-sourcing income under the treaty.
Hypothetical person. Illustrative figures in US dollars, rounded for the arithmetic. They are not current UK or US rates.
Alex is a US citizen, UK resident under Article 4, holding US shares in an ordinary brokerage account. Alex receives a portfolio dividend of USD 10,000.
| Step | Illustrative amount (USD) |
|---|---|
| US tax a non-citizen UK resident could bear under Article 10(2)(b) | 1,500 |
| UK tax on the dividend before any credit | 3,400 |
| UK credit, capped by Article 24(6)(b) at the treaty amount | 1,500 |
| UK tax payable after credit | 1,900 |
| US tax on the dividend before credit, at Alex's citizen rate | 2,400 |
| US credit for UK tax: the lower of 1,900 and (2,400 minus 1,500) | 900 |
| US tax payable after credit | 1,500 |
| Total tax across both countries | 3,400 |
The total equals the UK charge alone, so nothing is taxed twice and the US keeps exactly its treaty share. Had Alex's UK tax been lower than the US tax, the total would land on the US figure, with the US collecting the top-up. Treasury's examples in the technical explanation follow the same steps.
Untouched, because they are US domestic law, not treaty benefits. Article 1(2) says the treaty does not restrict any benefit given by either country's laws. Form 2555 under IRC section 911 and the Form 1116 credit therefore work as normal. The saving clause only stops the treaty adding relief on top of them.
For most Americans in London on salary, the Form 1116 credit does the heavy lifting. The saving clause bites at the edges: US-source investment income, pension lump sums, self-funded pensions and any position resting on an article outside Article 1(5). If your position turns on one of them, our US-UK tax specialists prepare the return, and an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified reviews and signs off every treaty position before anything is filed.