
UK rollover, incorporation and EIS deferral relief postpone the UK charge, but the IRS taxes the gain now. Why the later UK tax rarely gets credited.
When a UK relief defers a gain, the IRS still taxes that gain in the year you make it. Rollover relief, incorporation relief and EIS deferral relief all push the UK charge into a later year, and the UK tax that eventually arrives usually cannot be credited. Often, not claiming the relief is cheaper.
This is a different problem from the 5 April and 31 December mismatch, where one payment simply lands in an awkward year. Here the UK and the US tax the same gain in years that can sit far apart, and the foreign tax credit was never designed to bridge that kind of gap.
Because UK deferral reliefs are creatures of UK statute, and the Internal Revenue Code has no matching provision for most of them. The IRS computes your gain as if the UK relief did not exist, so the sale or transfer is a taxable event on your Form 1040 in the calendar year it happens.
Each relief works the same way in principle. The UK gain is not forgiven. It is subtracted from the base cost of something else, a replacement building, new shares in your company or EIS shares, and comes back into charge when that asset is sold. GOV.UK describes rollover relief as meaning you "will not pay any tax until you sell the new asset" (Business Asset Rollover Relief, GOV.UK). That is a postponement, and the US does not postpone with it.
| UK relief | What the UK does | What the US does | Must it be claimed? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Asset Rollover Relief (TCGA 1992 s.152) | Defers the gain on a trading asset into the cost of its replacement | Taxes the gain on the old asset in the year of sale, unless a US deferral of its own applies | Yes, on form HS290 |
| Incorporation relief (TCGA 1992 s.162) | Defers the gain on transferring a business to a company for shares | Section 367(a) makes the transfer to a foreign company a taxable event for a US person | Yes, for transfers on or after 6 April 2026 |
| EIS deferral relief | Defers a gain reinvested in EIS shares until those shares are disposed of | Taxes the original gain when it is realised | Yes |
| Gift holdover relief (s.165) | Defers the donor's gain on a gift of business assets | A gift is not a sale for US income tax, so there is no gain to tax either | Yes, jointly |
The last row is the useful contrast. Where both countries defer, nothing goes wrong. The trouble is confined to reliefs where only one side waits.
It is creditable in principle, but usually stranded in practice. The UK charges the deferred gain on a later disposal, when your US gain on the same asset is much smaller. The Form 1116 limitation caps the credit at US tax on that year's foreign income, so most of the UK tax becomes excess with nowhere to go.
The reason is the base cost. For the UK, the replacement asset or the shares carry a cost reduced by the deferred gain. For the US, they carry their real cost, because the gain was already taxed. Sell them and the UK sees two gains stacked together while the US sees one.
That excess is not wasted on paper. The Instructions for Form 1116 let you carry it back 1 year and then forward 10 years, applied within the same separate category, and they add that the period "can't be extended" (Instructions for Form 1116, IRS). The year the IRS taxed the original gain is usually several years behind the disposal, well outside a one-year carryback. Forward, the credit only helps if you later have foreign income in that category that the UK taxes more lightly than the US does, which is rare for someone still living in Britain. The mechanics of the carry itself are in our guide to foreign tax credit carryovers, baskets and the high-tax kickout.
No. Article 24 obliges the United States to give a credit for UK income tax, but only "in accordance with the provisions and subject to the limitations of the law of the United States". The carry periods and the limitation are those limitations. The treaty has no rule that moves a later UK charge back to the year the US taxed the gain.
The wording sits at the start of Article 24(1) of the 2001 convention (United Kingdom tax treaty documents, IRS). Article 26 lets the competent authorities consult on double taxation the convention does not otherwise resolve, and we would not rule that out on a large enough figure. It is a negotiation with two tax authorities, though, not a filing position, and nothing in the convention promises an answer.
Dana is hypothetical, and every figure here is illustrative, already converted to dollars at round rates so the arithmetic stays readable. She is a US citizen living in Manchester who runs a joinery business as a sole trader. In 2026 she sells her workshop building at a gain of USD 400,000 and buys a larger unit for USD 900,000. Five years later she sells that unit for USD 1,100,000, a further gain of USD 200,000 on both sides.
| Illustrative amounts (USD) | Route A: claims rollover relief | Route B: no claim |
|---|---|---|
| UK tax in 2026 | Nil, gain deferred | 96,000 |
| US tax in 2026 on the 400,000 gain | 80,000, nothing to credit | Nil after crediting 80,000 of the UK tax |
| UK tax in 2031 (Route A: 200,000 plus the deferred 400,000) | 144,000 | 48,000 |
| US tax in 2031 on the 200,000 gain | Nil after crediting 40,000 | Nil after crediting 40,000 |
| Excess UK credit left over | 104,000, carried back only to 2030 | 24,000, spread across both sale years |
| Total tax actually paid | 224,000 | 144,000 |
The gap of USD 80,000 is exactly the US tax on the original gain. Route A only closes it if Dana has general-category income in the carry window that the UK taxes lightly, or a bank of older credits in the right category to absorb the 2026 charge. Route A does let her keep the UK tax money for the years in between, which has real value, but here it costs more than it saves.
When the deferred UK gain may never be charged, or the US tax on the gain is small. If you expect to hold the replacement asset or the shares until death, the UK charge can disappear entirely, because there is no Capital Gains Tax on death. The US tax was due anyway, so deferral costs nothing.
Three situations come up most often:
Leaving the UK is not a reliable escape. Some deferred gains are revived on becoming non-resident, and UK land stays inside UK tax for non-residents.
Because the US does not just ignore the relief, it actively taxes the transfer. Section 367(a) treats a foreign company as not being a corporation when a US person moves property into it in an otherwise tax-free exchange, so the incorporation is a sale for the IRS even though the UK defers the gain completely.
Since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the old exception for property used in an active trade or business no longer applies to transfers after 31 December 2017. A US citizen landlord who moves a let portfolio into a UK company therefore faces US tax on the built-in gain at once, and the new company will usually bring Form 5471 reporting with it.
The UK side changed this year. Finance Act 2026 made incorporation relief something you must claim, by the first anniversary of the 31 January after the tax year of the transfer, and repealed the old election to switch it off, for transfers on or after 6 April 2026 (Finance Act 2026, section 39). For a US person that is helpful: doing nothing now means the UK taxes the gain in the same year as the US, which is the year the credit can actually work.
It is the most fragile of the three. A gain on shares is personal property, and IRS Publication 514 treats a US citizen with a foreign tax home as a nonresident for such a sale only if enough foreign income tax is paid on the gain. A deferred gain pays none, so in the sale year it is usually US-source and cannot use any credit at all.
The rest of the EIS position, including the income tax relief and the exemption on exit, is set out in our analysis of EIS and SEIS for US citizens and the PFIC question.
The decision is made in the year of the UK return, so it has to be modelled before then, not discovered when the later disposal happens. In order:
That is exactly the sort of two-country model our US-UK tax specialists build before a claim goes in. Every return we prepare is reviewed and signed by an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified, because half of this decision is British and half is American. If a UK sale, transfer or reinvestment is coming up, the useful moment to ask is before the UK claim is made, while both routes are still open.