
Adding a US-resident trustee usually keeps a UK trust UK resident, unless the settlor was not UK resident when settling. Then s.80 bites.
Appointing one US-resident trustee alongside UK-resident trustees usually leaves a UK trust UK resident: under ITA 2007 s.475 and TCGA 1992 s.69, a mixed trustee body is UK resident whenever a settlor was UK resident when settling. If the settlor was not, the same appointment exports the trust and triggers a CGT exit charge.
The US side runs on a different test. One American trustee almost never makes an English trust a US domestic trust, because the court test fails while the trust is run from London. The real US risk comes later, when a trust that did become domestic loses its American trustee.
For income tax and capital gains tax, the trustees of a settlement are treated as a single deemed person, and that person's residence is set by ITA 2007 s.475 (mirrored for gains by TCGA 1992 s.69). There are three outcomes:
Adding a Connecticut-resident trustee to two London trustees creates the third case, so what decides residence is the settlor's history.
Condition C, in s.476, looks at the settlor at the time the settlement was made, or immediately before death for a will trust. HMRC's manual adds that the test is also applied when the settlor later adds property. The Finance Act 2025 changed what counts: for settlements made on or after 6 April 2025 only the settlor's UK residence matters, while for earlier settlements s.476(3ZA) reads in "or domiciled in the United Kingdom", so either status meets the condition. HMRC also states that a pre-2025 trust to which property is added after that date picks up the new residence-only rule.
One trap catches US trust companies. Under s.475(6) and TCGA s.69(2D), a non-resident trustee acting in the course of a business carried on through a UK branch, agency or permanent establishment is treated as UK resident. A New York trust company appointed through its London office may count as a UK-resident trustee, whatever its own residence.
The appointment exports the trust whenever the settlor fails condition C. A typical case is an American who settled an English-law trust with London trustees while living in New York. With all-UK trustees the settlor's status never mattered. Add one US-resident trustee and the trust falls into the mixed case, where condition C is not met. The trust becomes non-UK resident on the day the deed takes effect.
The second route is quieter. A trust that is safely mixed today becomes non-resident the day its last UK-resident trustee retires, dies or moves abroad. HMRC's Capital Gains Manual notes that the exit charge usually arises because UK trustees retire and are replaced by non-residents.
Either way, TCGA 1992 s.80 applies. The trustees are deemed to dispose of the settled property and reacquire it at market value immediately before they cease to be resident. Assets used in a UK branch trade are carved out, as are assets a double tax treaty would keep outside UK tax. HMRC also confirms that assets still inside the non-resident capital gains rules, such as UK land, are outside the exit charge because they stay taxable. There is no cash to fund the bill: the gain is a paper gain on assets the trust still owns.
Inheritance tax is a separate question. Excluded property status turns on the settlor and where the assets are situated, not on where the trustees live. It needs its own analysis, and appointing a US trustee does not change it.
For US purposes a trust is domestic only if it passes both tests in Treas. Reg. §301.7701-7. Fail either and it is foreign.
The court test asks whether a US court can exercise primary supervision over the administration of the trust. The safe harbour requires three things: the trust instrument does not direct administration outside the United States, the trust is in fact administered exclusively in the United States, and there is no automatic migration clause. An English trust whose books, investment management and distribution decisions sit in London fails the safe harbour whoever its trustees are. The regulation's own first example is a trust administered abroad by a US trustee's foreign branch, and it is foreign.
The control test asks whether US persons control all the substantial decisions, with nobody else holding a veto. The regulation lists those decisions: distributions, selecting beneficiaries, allocating receipts between income and capital, terminating the trust, litigation, and adding, removing or replacing trustees. It counts everyone with authority over such a decision, not only the trustees, so a UK protector with a veto fails the test on its own.
The regulation's examples set out the arithmetic. Two US trustees and one non-resident alien deciding by unanimity fail the test, because nothing can be decided without the foreign trustee. The same three deciding by majority pass it.
So one US trustee among UK colleagues leaves an English trust foreign on both counts. Making it domestic takes deliberate work: a US majority, no foreign veto, and moving the administration to a US state. That is a migration project, not an appointment.
"US resident" and "US person" are not the same thing. A US citizen is a US person wherever they live; UK residence follows where a trustee actually lives.
| Proposed trustee | UK residence for s.475 / s.69 | US person for the control test |
|---|---|---|
| US citizen living in London | UK resident | Yes, a US person |
| British national living in New York | Non-UK resident | Yes, if a US resident alien |
| British national living in London | UK resident | No |
| US citizen living in Connecticut | Non-UK resident | Yes |
| US trust company acting through a London branch | Treated as UK resident (s.475(6)) | Yes, a domestic corporation |
| Guernsey or Jersey trust company | Non-UK resident | No |
The US citizen in London is the useful case. That trustee keeps a mixed body UK resident on the UK side while counting as a US decision-maker on the US side. For a family weighing an eventual move of the trust to the US, that keeps both options open.
Domestic to foreign. Under IRC §684(c), a trust that "becomes a foreign trust" is treated as transferring all its assets to a foreign trust immediately before the change. Under §684(a) that transfer is a deemed sale at market value. §684(b) switches the rule off to the extent a person is treated as the owner under the grantor trust rules. Treas. Reg. §1.684-4 frames the outbound charge around a domestic trust that a US person funded and that nobody owns under the grantor rules. For a trust funded by a UK settlor, whether gain arises depends on who funded it and on its grantor status. Get that question answered on the specific facts before the trust ever becomes domestic.
The inadvertent-change cure. If a decision-maker dies, becomes incapacitated, resigns or changes residence, and that would flip the trust's status without anyone intending it, §301.7701-7(d)(2) allows 12 months from the change to replace that person or fix their residence. Fix it in time and the trust keeps its old status throughout. Miss it and the status changes from the date of the original event. The IRS can extend the window for reasonable cause, but only where reasonable steps were already taken. A trustee who retires on purpose is not an inadvertent change.
Foreign to domestic. §684 has no inbound counterpart. But a foreign non-grantor trust usually carries accumulated income history into the move, so the US tax treatment of later distributions should be modelled before the trust is domesticated, not after.
On the US side, reporting attaches to owners, transferors and beneficiaries, not to the trustee's nationality. While the trust stays foreign, a US owner still makes sure Form 3520-A is filed, and US recipients of distributions still report them on Form 3520. The Form 3520-A instructions require the return to be signed by the trustee, so a newly appointed US trustee may end up signing it. If a domestic trust funded by a living US citizen or resident becomes foreign, the Form 3520 instructions treat its gross value as a reportable amount. See our guide to Form 3520 for US persons in the UK.
On the UK side, a UK-resident express trust stays registrable on the Trust Registration Service whatever its trustees' nationality, and the change of trustee has to be recorded there. If the trust becomes non-resident, the registration gateways narrow to UK land, UK tax liability and, while at least one trustee is UK resident, a UK business relationship. Our TRS guide for US-connected trusts walks through each gateway.
Eleanor settled a discretionary trust under English law in 2015 with two London trustees. It holds a listed portfolio worth about GBP 2.4m with a base cost of about GBP 1.1m. Her son lives in Boston and the family wants his cousin, a Connecticut resident, as a third trustee. These figures are illustrative.
Version A: Eleanor was UK resident in 2015. The trust becomes mixed, and condition C is met, so it stays UK resident. No s.80 charge arises. On the US side administration stays in London, so the court test fails and the trust remains foreign. Nothing changes except who signs the trust's US forms.
Version B: same facts, but both London trustees retire the following year. The cousin is now the only trustee, and he is non-UK resident. The trust becomes non-resident, and s.80 deems a disposal of the portfolio at about GBP 2.4m against the GBP 1.1m base cost. That is a paper gain of roughly GBP 1.3m, taxed on the trustees immediately before they leave UK residence.
Version C: Eleanor was living in New York in 2015 and was neither UK resident nor UK domiciled. Before the appointment, the all-UK trustee body made the trust UK resident. The day the cousin is appointed, the body becomes mixed, condition C fails, and the trust is exported. The s.80 charge in Version B arrives at signing rather than a year later.
One deed, three results, and only the settlor's history separates them.
| Question | If yes | If no |
|---|---|---|
| Was a settlor UK resident (or, pre-6 April 2025, UK domiciled) when settling or adding property? | A mixed body stays UK resident | The appointment exports the trust: model s.80 first |
| Will at least one UK-resident trustee remain after any planned retirement? | Residence holds | Exit charge on the last retirement |
| Is the new trustee acting through a UK branch? | Treated as UK resident | Use their actual residence |
| Does any non-US person hold a veto over a substantial decision? | Trust fails the control test, stays foreign | Check the court test next |
| Is the trust administered exclusively in a US state? | Court test safe harbour may be met | Trust is foreign whatever the trustee mix |
| Could a death or resignation flip US status? | Name a successor and plan around the 12-month window | No action |
We run every appointment through these questions on both sides before anything is signed, and the filings are reviewed and signed by an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified. If a trustee change is on your family's agenda, our US-UK private client tax team can model both residence tests and the s.80 position first. You can book a consultation when you are ready.