
Sold SAYE, SIP, CSOP or EMI shares while behind on US returns? What the streamlined returns must show: exercise income, US basis, the gain and FBARs.
Yes, you can still use the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedure after selling UK scheme shares. The catch is that the returns must pick up two separate events: compensation income when you exercised or received the shares, and a capital gain when you sold them, measured from a dollar basis that includes that income.
This is for a US citizen in the UK who joined Sharesave (SAYE), a Share Incentive Plan (SIP), a CSOP, EMI or an unapproved plan, sold the shares in earlier years, and never filed US returns or filed without mentioning them. The scheme rules are covered in our guides to SAYE and SIP for US citizens and EMI options for US citizens.
Every share event that falls in a year covered by the procedure. That means compensation income on Form 1040 for any exercise, award or vesting in the window, and the sale on Form 8949 and Schedule D for any disposal in the window. Foreign account reporting for the plan account runs on its own, longer timetable.
Under the IRS terms for US taxpayers residing outside the United States, you file delinquent or amended returns for the most recent three years whose due date has passed, and FinCEN Form 114 (the FBAR) for the most recent six years. Tax and interest are paid. The usual failure-to-file, accuracy and FBAR penalties are not charged if the conduct was non-willful and you meet the terms.
The procedure does not change how share income is taxed; it only fixes which years you report. If you are still deciding whether the route fits you, start with our page on the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedure.
The income event belongs to the year you exercised the option or became entitled to the shares, and the gain belongs to the year you sold. A same-day exercise and sale puts both events on one return, with a gain close to nil.
The usual position, scheme by scheme (plan rules and award letters decide the detail):
| Scheme | US income event (Form 1040) | Typical UK treatment | UK tax available to credit? |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAYE (Sharesave) | Spread at exercise: market value less option price. Bonus or interest on the savings contract is also US income. | No income tax at a normal exercise; CGT on sale from the option price | Only any CGT on the sale |
| CSOP | Spread at exercise | No income tax if the qualifying conditions are met; CGT on sale | Only any CGT on the sale |
| EMI | Spread at exercise | Little or no income tax if granted at market value; CGT on sale | Only any CGT on the sale |
| SIP partnership shares | The salary used to buy them is ordinary wages | Bought from pre-tax pay | Usually none |
| SIP free and matching shares | Value when awarded, or later if they can still be forfeited | No income tax if kept in the plan long enough; often no CGT if sold straight out of the plan | Usually none |
| Unapproved options or awards | Spread at exercise or value at vesting | Income tax and NIC through PAYE | Yes, the PAYE income tax |
The IRS explains the general rule for options that do not qualify under US statute in Topic 427, Stock options: income arises at exercise, measured by the spread. UK schemes are not built to the US statutory option rules, so they are normally treated as non-statutory. HMRC's own summary of the UK side is on GOV.UK's employee share schemes page.
You report the sale, but not the exercise year, and you still need the exercise-date value to work out the gain. The procedure does not ask for returns older than its window. The sale return, however, needs a basis, and that basis depends on the compensation that arose in a year you are not filing.
US rules build the basis of compensatory shares from what you paid plus the amount taxed as compensation. Where the exercise year falls outside the window, that compensation is never reported. Using the exercise-date value as basis anyway avoids taxing the same value as gain, and it is the approach most practitioners take. It is still a position, not a given. We record the exercise-date evidence and the reasoning in the workpapers so it can be defended if the IRS asks.
If both events fall inside the window, both go on the returns. If both fall before it, the returns show nothing for those shares, though the plan account may still sit inside the longer FBAR period.
Add what you paid for the shares to the compensation income recognised at exercise or award, converting each to dollars at the exchange rate on that date. For most scheme shares, that equals the market value on the exercise date in dollars. Sale proceeds are converted at the rate on the sale date.
Here is a worked example with illustrative figures and illustrative exchange rates. A US citizen in Leeds holds a SAYE option over 3,000 shares at an option price of GBP 3.00, funded by GBP 9,000 of savings. She exercises when the shares are worth GBP 4.50 and sells the following year at GBP 5.10.
| Step | GBP | Illustrative rate | USD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amount paid at exercise | 9,000 | 1.24 | 11,160 |
| Spread at exercise (US compensation, exercise-year return) | 4,500 | 1.24 | 5,580 |
| US basis | 13,500 | 16,740 | |
| Sale proceeds (sale-year return) | 15,300 | 1.28 | 19,584 |
| US capital gain | 2,844 | ||
| UK chargeable gain (proceeds less option price) | 6,300 |
Across the two US returns she reports USD 5,580 of compensation and USD 2,844 of gain. The UK sees one gain of GBP 6,300 and, if that was covered by her annual exempt amount and she had no other gains, no UK tax at all. Copying the UK figure across would overstate the US gain and miss the compensation entirely.
The US holding period runs from exercise, and the US matches lots specifically or first-in, first-out where the UK pools them, which can widen the difference.
Because the UK reliefs that made the scheme attractive have no US equivalent, and you cannot credit UK tax that was never charged. The gap is widest for SIP shares and for SAYE, CSOP or EMI exercises where the UK charged nothing at exercise.
SIP shares show it most clearly. In the UK, partnership shares come out of pre-tax salary, and free and matching shares held long enough and sold straight out of the plan usually carry no income tax or capital gains tax. For US purposes the salary is wages, the free and matching shares are compensation, any dividend shares are dividend income, and the sale produces a gain measured from the US basis. With no UK tax on any of it, the foreign tax credit has nothing to work with.
The exclusion on Form 2555 can cover the compensation element, because it is pay for work done in the UK. It cannot cover the capital gain, which is not earned income. Any gain relief comes through Form 1116, and only to the extent UK tax was actually paid on it.
Two limits apply to the compensation. First, it is earned income for the period of service it relates to, often grant to exercise, so days worked in the US during that period make part of it US source. Second, Publication 54 treats pay as earned in the year the work was done; it can only be excluded against that year's limit, and pay received later than the year after the work cannot be excluded at all. Option spreads that relate to services several years back can fall foul of that rule.
For unapproved schemes, the PAYE income tax on exercise is creditable on Form 1116, often a better result than the exclusion. UK capital gains tax on the sale goes in the passive category, but whether a US citizen's gain counts as foreign source needs checking against the sourcing rules and the treaty first.
A UK nominee or brokerage account holding vested scheme shares is generally a foreign financial account, so it counts towards the FBAR for each year it held them, and it may belong on Form 8938 too. The FBAR window is longer than the return window, so a sale years ago can still mean FBAR entries now.
Count the account in the maximum-value test for every year in the FBAR period, even one outside the three returns. A SAYE savings contract may also be reportable in its own right. SIP shares sit in a plan trust until withdrawn, and how that trust is treated for US purposes needs a look before the forms are drafted. Form 8938 follows its own thresholds, which depend on filing status and living abroad, and it is attached to each return in the window where you cross them.
Say what actually happened, in your own words, with dates. Form 14653 asks for the specific reasons you did not report. For share schemes the honest story is often simple: the employer described the plan as tax-free, no US tax forms were issued, and you did not know US rules applied to a UK employer's plan.
Name the schemes, roughly when you joined, exercised and sold, and how you found out. If you filed US returns that left the shares out, say why. A statement that just says "I was not aware" is the most common reason these certifications get questioned. Our guide to writing the Form 14653 statement goes through the structure.
At Next Tax Source, share scheme catch-up returns are prepared to a ready-to-sign state and reviewed and signed by an IRS Enrolled Agent who is also ACCA-qualified, so the UK scheme rules and the US treatment are read together. You can see what a catch-up costs on our pricing page or book a consultation with your plan statements to hand.